Category Archives: 1940s

Representative rugby

Worksop College recently published a new webpage to encourage people to apply for rugby scholarships (wsnl.co.uk/college/rugby). One key thing missing from this page however, is a list of representative players – something that has never been produced. However, I am gradually getting round to documenting this rather long list. Records were kept a lot more diligently in the years before technology and as a result, documenting the early successes in this area was quite straightforward.

A few things to note:

  • Where a player is listed more than once (i.e. he played representative rugby in more than one season), on his final mention his other representative honours will also be listed (i.e. club, country etc)
  • The Northern/Midlands/Southern Public Schools XV were pretty much the equivalent to the current schools regional setup
  • The England/Scotland Public Schools XV was pretty much equivalent to the current England/Scotland schools teams up until the 1950s
  • Worksop College were pretty good at rugby in the old days!

1921 – 1950

Season Name Schoolboy teams Post-schoolboy teams/other
1928/1929 G.Laing Northern Public Schools Blackheath, Army
1929/1930 G.C.V. Knowlson England Public Schools
1930/1931 W.P. Heath Northern Public Schools, England Public Schools
D.R. McLennan Scotland Public Schools, Northern Public Schools
1932/1933 F. Martin England Public Schools, Northern Public Schools Oxford University
G.H. Stephens Northern Public Schools
H.D. Venables Northern Public Schools
1934/1935 W.R. Andrews Scottish Public Schools, Northern Public Schools
K. Hall Northern Public Schools Cambridge University
1935/1936 R.S. Stephens Northern Public Schools
H.F. Barker Northern Public Schools
1936/1937 H.F. Barker England Public Schools, Northern Public Schools
1937/1938 H.F. Barker England Public Schools, Northern Public Schools
D. Collinge Northern Public Schools
J.S. Pinkney Northern Public Schools
P.E.F. Rhodes Northern Public Schools
J.B.C Teale Northern Public Schools
1938/1939 E.D.W. Paul Northern Public Schools
J.S. Pinkney Scotland Public Schools, Northern Public Schools
A.L. Evans Northern Public Schools
P.E.F. Rhodes Northern Public Schools Leicester
A.J.A. Ferguson Northern Public Schools
1939/1940 A.L. Evans Northern Public Schools Cambridge University, The Army, England
R.W.J. Naismith Northern Public Schools
1940/1941 G.C. Buchanan Northern Public Schools
P.T. Francis Northern Public Schools
1941/1942 H.D. Jennison The Rest Vs Home Counties
T.A.S. Anderson Northern Public Schools
P. Carmichael Northern Public Schools
1942/1943 N.M. Hall Northern Public Schools (Captain), Midland Public Schools Army (Captain), St Mary’s Hospital, Richmond, England (Captain)
C.H. Ewart Northern Public Schools, Midland Public Schools
W.G. Briggs Northern Public Schools
E.R. Holliday Northern Public Schools
J.M. Taylor Northern Public Schools
T. Bennett Northern Public Schools
D.W. Hardy Northern Public Schools

 

Rugby in the early 1940s

Over the course of the 1941/1942 and 1942/1943 seasons, Worksop College produced two of the best schoolboy rugby teams in the country. How these teams would get on against modern schoolboy rugby teams we will never know – but the below gives an indication of just how good the teams were. Here we look at the 1941/1942 XV which was probably the better of the two XVs.

1941/1942 season report
Comparisons are usually described as odious, and it is perhaps unwise at such times to make them. We can, however, safely say that we have had one of the best XV.s ever in the School this term and easily the most successful season on record, particularly when one considers the opposition encountered. Such an eminent rugger authority as R.F. Oakes of the Yorkshire Union, has stated that “Worksop is the best School XV in the country.” We do not ourselves feel justified in saying that, but we certainly have al very good and well-balanced side. Well-balanced is probably the key-note, for the XV is without official ” stars,” but has many good players who combine superbly. The foundation of success has been a hard-working and lively pack, well led by H.D. ]ennison, a fine forward in every way; outstanding have been T.A.S. Anderson, G.S. Joss and E. Hall, while D.F. Batchelor has improved steadily as hooker. Behind the scrum, J.M. Taylor and N.M. Hall have been a good pair of halves, serving their threequarter line well, while the line itself has always been fast and accurate in its passing, with much thrust from P. Carmichael, J.B. MilIar and E.R. Holliday. Behind this line, W.G. Briggs has been an enterprising and reliable full-back, while N.M. Hall’s place-kicking and other kicking have been invaluable.

Results: played 11, won 11, points for 389, points against 12

C.S. Hardern’s XV Home Won 43-0
RAF Swinderby Home Won 16-3
RAF Syerston Home Won 53-3
RAF Finningly Home Won 26-0
Old Worksopians Home Won 31-0
Mount Saint Mary’s College Home Won 63-0
Saint Peter’s School, York Away Won 28-0
Sedbergh School Home Won 30-0
Ampleforth College Away Won 6-3
Trent College Home Won 76-0
Denstone College Away Won 17-3

Characters of the XV

  • H. D. Jennison (captain), forward – a magnificent all-round player, particularly  good in the line-outs-an inspiration to the XV and one of the best captains, on and off the field, the School have ever had
  • T. A. S. Anderson (vice-captain), forward – unlucky in his injury early in the  term, he has. been an untiring worker since he returned and is a fine forward,  particularly outstanding in the line out
  • N. M. Hall, stand-off half – has developed more speed and has learnt how to find an opening and sell a dummy. A fine natural player, and a beautiful kicker  with either foot – he has been a tower of strength to the side, considering his age, and in another year should be excellent
  • P. Carmichael, centre – a player of great possibilities-fine natural thrust and pace, good hands and defence, he has found many gaps in the opposition defence and always tries hard
  • J. B. Millar, centre – a sound and steady player, with a rock-like defence, who
    held the line together and was deceptively better than he appeared
  • G. S. Joss, forward – a fine player; who, with his great pace, was always in  everything. A minor fault is a tendency to high tackling-when he cures this, he will be really class
  • E. Hall, forward – a hard-working scrummager, who has vastly improved in the  loose and has always worked hard. I wish he would learn to pass
  • P. J. Walker, forward – another fine scrummaging forward-always on the ball­ but I wish he would pass and also learn all the rules
  • D. F. Batchelor, forward – has hooked well and has improved greatly; he has now discovered that there is more in forward play than hooking and is starting to do it
  • E. R. Holliday, wing-threequarter – one of the most dangerous attackers on the
    side great pace, clever and a fine defence, he shouid be absolutely first  class next year.
  • T. B. Greenwood, forward – a vastly improved player, who has worked hard and  has improved his own individual play; a good scrummager
  • W. G. Briggs, full back – a very sound and intelligent player, who opens up the  game well : tackling most reliable, particularly in an emergency-but he  must try not to score tries, even when tempted greatly
  • J. M. Taylor, scrum-half – has toiled hard and has improved every match, so  that he is now a good player; his all-round play has been as sound as ever and his passing is now much quicker
  • J. W. Phillips, forward – always on the ball and excelling in the line-outs, a lively and useful forward in the loose
  • C. H. Ewart, wing-threequarter – filled E. P. Clark’s place well and could  always be relied upon; a little too orthodox and easy to tackle, but will alter this by next year, when he should be a fine player
  • E. P. Clark, wing-threequarter – in good form until York match, when he left us  for the Navy; much faster and steadier on his feet, he was a dangerous attacking wing

What became of the members of the team?

  • Jennison, Anderson and Millar were killed in Normandy at the Battle of the Falaise Pocket in 1944 where they were all tank captains
  • N.M. Hall went on to captain England and was the first player to score a 3 point penalty in 1948
  • Carmichael joined the navy and found fame during the Cold War for downing a jet-engined Russian Mig fighter from a piston-engined Sea Hawker – the only recorded incident of its kind

Peter “Hoagy” Carmichael

Peter Carmichael (Pelham 1936-1941) was a fine rugby player and a key member of the famously undefeated Worksop College rugby XV for 1941-1942. Carmichael played for multiple representative rugby sides in his last year at Worksop including the Northern Public Schools XV and the Rest of England XV – all of the sides he played in, won!

Peter Carmichael on the ball

Peter Carmichael with one of his trademarks swerves en route to scoring a try at Worksop in 1941

After Worksop, Carmichael joined the Royal Navy as a combat pilot and it was during the Korean War that he became famous for shooting down a jet-engined MiG 15 whilst piloting a piston-engined Hawker Sea Fury:

“Eight MiGs came at us out of the sun. I did not see them at first, and my No. 4, ‘Smoo’ Ellis, gave a break when he noticed tracer streaming past his fuselage.”

“We all turned towards the MiGs and commenced a ‘scissors’. It soon became apparent that four MiGs were after each section of two Furies, but by continuing our break turns, we presented impossible targets. They made no attempt to bracket us. One MiG came at me head on. I saw his heavy tracer shells. I fired a burst, then he flashed past me. I believe Carl got some hits on him too. This aircraft then broke away, and went head on to my Nos 3 and 4, Lieutenant Pete Davies and ‘Smoo’ Ellis. They were seen to get good hits on one who broke away with smoke coming from him.” Take Off magazine, Part 84, pp. 2338–2339.

Peter Carmichael died in 1997 and the below photo of him appeared alongside his obituary from the Guardian.

Peter Carmichael

Peter Carmichael alongside a Hawker Sea Fury